Israeli Legislation.com

Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commissioner Law, 5776-2016

חוק נציבות תלונות הציבור על מייצגי המדינה בערכאות, תשע"ו-2016

Published: 2016-08-11Consolidated Hebrew text as of 2026-09-05 · Last amended 2016-08-11✓ Amendment status checked against the Knesset legislation record on 2026-09-05
Premium
Unofficial English translation — for reference only. It may contain errors or omissions and cannot be relied on as a legal text. Only the Hebrew text published in Reshumot is legally binding.More

This English text was translated from the official Hebrew using a range of translation tools, and it undergoes ongoing checks and updates. It is not a certified translation.

Despite these checks, it may contain errors, omissions, or imprecise renderings of legal terminology and cross-references, and it may not yet reflect the latest amendments. It cannot be relied upon as a legal text.

The Hebrew text as published in Reshumot (ספר החוקים) and on the Knesset website is the sole authoritative and legally binding version. In any discrepancy, the Hebrew text prevails.

This translation is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For use in legal proceedings, request a certified Expert Legal Opinion.

Chapter IV: Miscellaneous Provisions

Report§

20.
(a)The Commissioner shall submit to the Minister and to the Attorney General, annually, a report for the preceding year (hereinafter – annual report), containing a review that shall address, inter alia, the activities of the Commission in the following matters, broken down by type of state representative in courts and by the bodies or units within the framework of which they are employed:
(1)the number of complaints filed and the number of complaints examined;
(2)the number of complaints found to be justified;
(3)the reasons for non-examination of the complaints;
(4)the average examination time for complaints that were examined;
(5)the number of complaints whose examination has not yet been completed;
(6)the types of matters in respect of which complaints were filed;
(7)the principal recommendations for handling and remedying deficiencies;
(8)the number of complaints that raised a concern of a criminal offence or of a disciplinary offence, if any;
(9)a description of the handling of complaints without specifying personal details or details that may lead to the identification of the complainant, the respondent or any other person.
(b)The Commissioner shall deliver a copy of the annual report to the responsible Ministers.
(c)The Commissioner may submit to the responsible Minister and to the Attorney General a special report prior to the submission of the annual report.
(d)The Minister shall publish to the public every report submitted to the Minister pursuant to this section, in the manner the Minister sees fit.

Confidentiality§

21.
(a)The Commissioner and the employees of the Commission are obliged to keep secret any information that has come to their knowledge by reason of their work, not to make use of it and not to disclose it to another, except for the purpose of carrying out their functions and duties under this Law; the Commissioner and the employees of the Commission shall sign a confidentiality undertaking upon commencing their work.
(b)Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a) –
(1)the Attorney General may obtain a copy of any material or information in the possession of the Commissioner or the employees of the Commission that was submitted in the course of the performance of their duties; however, material or information concerning a particular complaint shall be transmitted only after the handling thereof has been completed;
(2)the responsible Minister may obtain a copy of any material or information in the possession of the Commissioner or the employees of the Commission that was obtained in the course of the performance of their duties and that the responsible Minister requires for the purpose of exercising the Minister's authority to initiate disciplinary proceedings; however, material or information concerning a particular complaint shall be transmitted only after the handling thereof has been completed;
(3)if the Commissioner considers that special circumstances exist that justify doing so, the Commissioner may transmit a copy of any material or information in the Commissioner's possession or in the possession of the employees of the Commission to the responsible Minister for the purpose of exercising the Minister's authority to initiate disciplinary proceedings, or to the Attorney General, even if the handling of the complaint has not yet been completed;
(4)if the Commissioner considers, in the course of the investigation of a complaint, that the material or information that has come into the Commissioner's possession warrants a systemic audit, the Commissioner may transmit it to the attention of the State Comptroller, excluding personal details of the person complained against or details that could lead to that person's identification.
(c)Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (b)(2) and (3), the Attorney General may determine that there is an impediment to transmitting the material or information referred to in that subsection to the responsible Minister, on grounds of concern for significant harm to a vital public interest.
(d)The Minister and the Attorney General together may authorise the publication of the particulars of a specific complaint the handling of which has been completed, including a summary of the findings of the investigation, if it is found that there is a public interest justifying the infringement of privacy entailed thereby, and after a person who may be harmed by the publication has been given an adequate opportunity to state his or her arguments.

Restrictions on Publication and Disclosure of Information§

22.
(a)Material or information transmitted by the Commissioner pursuant to section 17(e), a notice or decision of the Commissioner pursuant to sections 18(d) or 19, and a report pursuant to section 20, shall not include or disclose material or information in respect of which one of the following applies:
(1)the Prime Minister, the Minister of Defence or the Minister of Foreign Affairs, as the case may be, has notified the Commissioner in writing that their disclosure is liable to harm the security of the State or its foreign relations and a certificate of privilege in the interest of the State or a certificate of privilege in the public interest may be issued in respect thereof pursuant to section 44 of the Evidence Ordinance [New Version], 5731-1971 (in this Law – the Evidence Ordinance);
(2)a Minister of the Government has notified the Commissioner in writing that their disclosure is liable to harm an important public interest and a certificate of public interest privilege may be issued in respect thereof pursuant to section 45 of the Evidence Ordinance;
(3)their publication or disclosure is prohibited by law;
(4)the information relates to internal deliberations, records of internal consultations or of things said in the framework of an internal debriefing, or an opinion, draft, advice or recommendation given for the purpose of making a decision, other than consultations prescribed by law;
(5)they are liable to unlawfully harm the privacy of a person;
(6)they are liable to unlawfully harm the rights of a person other than the complainant;
(7)they constitute the disclosure of a professional secret or confidential information within the meaning thereof under any law.
(b)If the Commissioner considers that material or information being transmitted, a notice, decision or report as referred to in subsection (a) is liable to include or disclose information as referred to in subsection (a)(1) and (2), and no notification in that matter has been received from the Prime Minister or the Minister concerned as referred to in that subsection, the Commissioner shall request the position of the Prime Minister or the Minister concerned before publishing the information; if the Prime Minister or the Minister concerned has not notified the Commissioner of their position within 30 days of the date of the Commissioner's request, they shall be deemed to have no objection to the publication of the information.
(c)If the Commissioner considers that one of the cases listed in subsection (a) applies, the Commissioner may transmit the material or information, the notice, the decision or the report as referred to in that subsection, after making amendments, omissions or imposing conditions, or may transmit them only to some of the bodies to which they are to be transmitted under this Law; if the Commissioner has acted as referred to in this subsection, the Commissioner shall indicate this upon transmission as aforesaid, unless there is an impediment to doing so for the reasons set out in subsection (a).

Admissibility of Documents§

23.

A report, decision, opinion and any other document prepared by the Commissioner or the employees of the Commission in the course of the performance of their duties, as well as a notice received by the Commissioner or the employees of the Commission in the course of the performance of their duties, shall not serve as evidence in legal or disciplinary proceedings, except in criminal proceedings for the giving of false testimony.

Rights and Remedies§

24.
(a)The decisions and findings of the Commissioner in respect of a complaint –
(1)shall not confer upon the complainant or any other person any right or remedy, before a court or tribunal, that the complainant or other person did not previously have;
(2)shall not prevent the complainant or any other person from exercising a right or seeking a remedy to which the complainant or other person is entitled; however, if a time limit has been set therefor by legislation, that time limit shall not be extended by the filing or investigation of the complaint.
(b)A court shall not entertain an application for a remedy against the Commissioner's decisions and findings in respect of a complaint.

Publication of Notices§

25.

A notice of the ways in which a complaint may be filed under this Law and a statement of the principal powers of the Commissioner prescribed in this Law shall be published in such manner as the Minister shall determine.

Implementation and Regulations§

26.

The Minister is responsible for the implementation of this Law, and may, with the approval of the Constitution, Law and Justice Committee of the Knesset, make Regulations for its implementation.

Preservation of Powers to Investigate Complaints under Other Laws§

27.

Nothing in the powers of the Commissioner under this Law shall derogate –

(1)from the powers of any body vested with authority to investigate complaints under any law;
(2)from the powers of the Attorney General to conduct investigations concerning the conduct of state representatives in courts or from any other power vested in the Attorney General;
(3)from the powers of the State Attorney, the head of the prosecution division of the Israel Police, the head of the traffic branch of the Israel Police, and any other person in charge of state representatives in courts, or their representatives, to conduct investigations concerning the conduct of state representatives in courts over whom they are in charge, or from any other power vested in them.

Systemic Audit by the State Comptroller§

28.
(a)The State Comptroller shall establish, within the Office of the State Comptroller, a team that shall conduct an audit of the apparatus of state representatives in courts, in accordance with the powers of the State Comptroller under any law.
(b)Nothing in the provisions of subsection (a) shall derogate from the powers of the State Comptroller under any law.

Amendment to the Freedom of Information Law – No. 14§

29.

In the Freedom of Information Law, 5758-1998, in section 14(a), at the end thereof the following shall be inserted:

"(16) the Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commission – with respect to the investigation of a complaint under the Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commissioner Law, 5776-2016."

Commencement§

30.

Section 28 shall commence six months from the date of its publication.

Transitional Provisions§

31.
(a)The provisions of this Law shall also apply to complaints that were filed with the Inspection Commission for the Prosecution Apparatus and State Representation in Courts (in this section – the outgoing Commission) that operated on the eve of the publication of this Law (hereinafter – the commencement date), and the investigation of which has not yet been completed, with respect only to investigation acts that have not yet been carried out.
(b)
(1)If the Commissioner appointed under this Law for the first time considers that it is possible to complete a particular systemic audit that the outgoing Commission had commenced and to publish a report thereon within six months of the date of commencement of the Commissioner's tenure, the Commissioner shall complete the examination and publish the report within that period, provided that the draft report was finalised before the commencement date;
(2)in acting as referred to in paragraph (1), the Commissioner may act in accordance with the principles document concerning the outgoing Commission dated the 12th of Tishrei 5774 (16 September 2013);
(3)notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (2), the provisions of sections 21(a) and (b)(1), 22 and 23 shall apply, with the necessary modifications, to the Commissioner and the employees of the Commission, and to their actions and publications or transmissions of information on their behalf, with respect to actions as referred to in paragraph (1);
(4)the Commissioner shall transmit to the State Comptroller, within six months of the date of commencement of the Commissioner's tenure, every document, information or other material in the possession of the outgoing Commission or the Commission that was prepared or collected in connection with a systemic audit; such document, information and material shall not be used for the investigation of complaints under the State Comptroller Law or this Law;
(5)if a report as referred to in paragraph (1) gives rise to a suspicion of a criminal offence, the Commissioner shall bring the matter to the attention of the Attorney General; if a report as referred to in paragraph (1) gives rise to a suspicion of a disciplinary offence, the Commissioner shall bring the matter to the attention of the responsible Minister and the Attorney General.
(c)The provisions of section 23 shall also apply to complaints filed with the outgoing Commission, unless the documents listed in that section have been used in legal or disciplinary proceedings.
(d)
(1)The provisions of section 14(a)(16) of the Freedom of Information Law, 5758-1998, as worded in this Law, shall also apply to complaints filed with the outgoing Commission, unless a request for information concerning them under that Law was filed on the eve of the commencement date;
(2)if a request as referred to in paragraph (1) was filed on the eve of the commencement date, no personal details or details that could lead to the identification of a state representative in courts shall be transmitted in response to that request.

Schedule (Section 15(c))

Complainant's Declaration

I declare that –

(1)the information I have provided in the paragraphs of my complaint is true;
(2)the information I have provided in the paragraphs of my complaint is true to the best of my knowledge and belief.

_________________

Signature of Declarant

I, the undersigned, hereby certify that on the __ day of __, there appeared before me a person known to me personally / whom I identified by identity number __, and after I cautioned that person that he or she must tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, and that he or she would be liable to the penalties prescribed by law if he or she fails to do so, the person confirmed the correctness of his or her declaration and signed it before me.

_________________

Signature of Declarant

Benjamin Netanyahu Ayelet Shaked

Prime Minister Minister of Justice

Reuven Rivlin Yuli-Yoel Edelstein

President of the State Speaker of the Knesset

Page 2 of 2

Read the entire law on one page — continuous text, no page breaks, plus formal citations.