Israeli Legislation.com

Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commissioner Law, 5776-2016

חוק נציבות תלונות הציבור על מייצגי המדינה בערכאות, תשע"ו-2016

Published: 2016-08-11Consolidated Hebrew text as of 2026-09-05 · Last amended 2016-08-11✓ Amendment status checked against the Knesset legislation record on 2026-09-05
Premium
Unofficial English translation — for reference only. It may contain errors or omissions and cannot be relied on as a legal text. Only the Hebrew text published in Reshumot is legally binding.More

This English text was translated from the official Hebrew using a range of translation tools, and it undergoes ongoing checks and updates. It is not a certified translation.

Despite these checks, it may contain errors, omissions, or imprecise renderings of legal terminology and cross-references, and it may not yet reflect the latest amendments. It cannot be relied upon as a legal text.

The Hebrew text as published in Reshumot (ספר החוקים) and on the Knesset website is the sole authoritative and legally binding version. In any discrepancy, the Hebrew text prevails.

This translation is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For use in legal proceedings, request a certified Expert Legal Opinion.

Chapter I: Definitions

Definitions§

1.

In this Law –

"forum" – a court, a tribunal established by law, an appeals committee, an arbitrator, a mediator, a body before which disciplinary proceedings are conducted by law, and any authority exercising judicial power, except a military tribunal or military court;

"state representative in courts" –

(1)a person who represents the State, pursuant to law, in proceedings heard before forums;
(2)a person who represents pursuant to section 2 of the Procedure Ordinance (Appearance of the Attorney General) [New Version];
(3)a prosecutor as defined in section 12(a) of the Criminal Procedure Law [Consolidated Version], 5742-1982;
(4)a person authorised by the Attorney General pursuant to section 258 of the Planning and Building Law, 5725-1965;
(5)a person who holds prosecution authority pursuant to section 264 of the Municipalities Ordinance;
(6)a person who represents in criminal proceedings pursuant to a power of attorney granted to that person under section 196 of the Local Councils Order (A), 5711-1950, or under section 233 of the Local Councils Order (Regional Councils), 5718-1958;

"the Commissioner" – a person appointed pursuant to section 2(a);

"the Commission" – the Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commission;

"the responsible Minister" – the Minister responsible for the body by which the state representative in courts is employed;

"the Minister" – the Minister of Justice.

Chapter II: Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commission

Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commissioner§

2.
(a)The Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Internal Security and the Attorney General, and after consultation with the President of the Supreme Court, shall appoint a person who is qualified to serve as a judge of the Supreme Court and who has familiarity with the field of State representation in courts, to the position of Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commissioner; the Commissioner shall head a unit within the Ministry of Justice that shall examine complaints in accordance with the provisions of this Law, and shall be called the "Public Complaints on State Representatives in Courts Commission".
(b)A person shall not be appointed to the position of Commissioner if that person has been convicted of a criminal offence or a disciplinary offence which, by reason of its nature, gravity or consequences, renders that person unfit, in the opinion of the Minister, after consultation with the Attorney General, to serve as Commissioner, or if an indictment has been filed against that person for a criminal offence as aforesaid and a final judgment has not yet been given in that person's matter.
(c)The obligation to hold a tender pursuant to section 19 of the State Service (Appointments) Law, 5719-1959, shall not apply to the appointment of the Commissioner.
(d)Notice of the appointment of the Commissioner shall be published in Reshumot (Official Gazette).

Time of Selection of the Commissioner§

3.

The appointment of a Commissioner shall be made, as far as possible, between 90 and 30 days before the end of the term of office of the incumbent Commissioner; if the position of Commissioner becomes vacant before the end of the term of office, the appointment shall be made within 45 days from the day on which the position became vacant as aforesaid.

Duration of Term§

4.

The Commissioner shall serve a single term of office of five years only.

End of Term§

5.
(a)The Commissioner shall cease to serve before the end of the term of office in any of the following:
(1)the death of the Commissioner;
(2)the resignation of the Commissioner, by delivery of a letter of resignation to the Minister;
(3)the removal of the Commissioner from office pursuant to section 6.
(b)Notice of the end of the term of office of the Commissioner shall be published in Reshumot (Official Gazette).

Removal from Office, Filing of Indictment and Suspension§

6.
(a)The Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Internal Security and the Attorney General, may remove the Commissioner from office if any of the following occurs:
(1)the Commissioner has been convicted of a criminal offence or a disciplinary offence as referred to in section 2(b), or an indictment has been filed against the Commissioner for a criminal offence as referred to in that section;
(2)the Commissioner has conducted himself or herself in a manner unbecoming of the Commissioner's status;
(3)the Commissioner is not performing the Commissioner's duties properly.
(b)The Minister shall not remove the Commissioner from office except after having given the Commissioner a suitable opportunity to state the Commissioner's arguments.
(c)An indictment shall not be filed against the Commissioner, except for offences listed in section 7(a)(2) of the Knesset Law, 5754-1994, except with the approval of the Attorney General; if an indictment is filed as aforesaid, the Commissioner shall be suspended from office until a final judgment is given in the Commissioner's matter.

Restriction on Occupation§

7.

The Commissioner shall not, in addition to the Commissioner's duties under this Law, perform the function of an internal auditor pursuant to the Internal Audit Law, 5752-1992.

Cooling-off Period§

8.

A person who has served as Commissioner shall not serve as a state representative in courts and shall not be employed in a body or unit, as the case may be, whose function is the representation of the State in courts and within the framework of which state representatives in courts are employed, until one year has elapsed from the day on which that person's service as Commissioner ended.

Independence§

9.

The Commissioner and the employees of the Commission shall be subject to no authority in matters of the performance of their duties under this Law, other than the authority of the law.

Employees of the Commission§

10.

The Commissioner and the employees of the Commission shall be State employees.

Budget of the Commission§

11.

The budget of the Commission shall be prepared by the Minister in coordination with the Commissioner and shall be determined in the annual State budget law, in a separate programme, within the framework of the budget item of the Ministry of Justice; in this section, "programme" and "budget item" – as defined in an annual budget law, as defined in the Budget Foundations Law, 5745-1985.

Chapter III: Examination of Complaints

Filing a complaint§

12.
(a)Any person who considers himself directly harmed by an act of a state representative in courts performed in the course of that representative's handling of a particular matter within the framework of that representative's role as a state representative in courts, where the act is contrary to law or without lawful authority or contrary to proper administration or constitutes improper conduct or behaviour, may file a complaint with the Commissioner; for this purpose, "act" includes an omission.
(b)Where the Minister or the Attorney General addressed the Commissioner in writing and requested that the Commissioner conduct an examination of an act as referred to in subsection (a) of a state representative in courts, the address shall be deemed a complaint filed under this Chapter.
(c)Where the Commissioner becomes aware of an act of a state representative in courts performed in the course of that representative's handling of a particular matter within the framework of that representative's role as a state representative in courts, and the act is contrary to law or without lawful authority, the Commissioner may transmit the information on the matter to the Attorney General.
(d)A complainant who does not know the identity of the state representative in courts who performed an act as referred to in subsection (a) may indicate, as the respondent in the complaint referred to in that subsection, the body or unit, as the case may be, within the framework of which the said state representative in courts is employed.
(e)Where a person as referred to in subsection (a) filed a complaint and has died, that person's spouse, child, parent, brother or sister may notify the Commissioner of that person's wish to continue with the complaint, and upon giving such notice, that person shall stand in the place of the complainant; a family member as aforesaid may file a complaint on behalf of a person who died without having filed a complaint, in respect of an act as referred to in subsection (a) that was performed against that person.

Manner of Filing a Complaint§

13.
(a)A complaint shall be submitted to the Commissioner in writing, signed by the complainant, and shall set out the name of the complainant, the complainant's identity number and address, and the particulars of the respondent as referred to in section 12(a) or (d), as the case may be; the complainant shall attach to the complaint all documents in the complainant's possession relating to the complaint.
(b)In the complaint, the complainant shall indicate whether the complainant has applied to a forum or to another body authorised to examine complaints pursuant to law, and shall attach all documents relating to that application.

Complaint by a Person Held in Custody§

14.

A complaint by a person as referred to in paragraphs (1) to (4) shall be submitted in a sealed envelope to the officeholder as detailed in those paragraphs, or to a person authorised by that officeholder for this purpose, and the officeholder shall transfer it, without opening it, to the Commissioner:

(1)a prisoner as defined in the Prison Ordinance [New Version], 5732-1971 – to the governor of the prison in which the prisoner is held;
(2)a detainee as defined in the Criminal Procedure (Enforcement Powers – Arrests) Law, 5756-1996, or a prisoner held in a remand centre – to the commander of the remand centre in which the detainee or prisoner is held;
(3)a person imprisoned pursuant to the Military Justice Law, 5715-1955 – to the commander of the detention facility in which that person is held;
(4)a person held in custody pursuant to law – to the administrator of the custody facility in which that person is held.

Examination of Complaints§

15.
(a)Upon the filing of a complaint, the Commissioner shall acknowledge its receipt and shall commence examination of the matter, unless the Commissioner finds that it is not to be examined pursuant to the provisions of section 16.
(b)Examination of the complaint shall be conducted only in respect of an act as referred to in section 12(a) and in respect of state representatives in courts.
(c)If the Commissioner finds, in accordance with the provisions of this Law, that the complaint is to be examined, the Commissioner shall notify the complainant thereof and shall decide whether to request from the complainant a statutory declaration in support of the facts set out in the complaint, in accordance with the form in the Schedule; such a statutory declaration may also be signed before the Commissioner or any of the employees of the Commission.

Complaints That Are Not to Be Examined or Whose Examination Requires Special Reason§

16.
(a)The Commissioner shall not examine a complaint if any of the following applies to it:
(1)the complaint is not about an act of a state representative in courts or is not about an act as referred to in section 12(a);
(2)the complaint is frivolous or vexatious on its face or concerns trivial matters;
(3)the complaint raises a substantial concern of the commission of a criminal offence; a complaint as referred to in this paragraph shall be transferred by the Commissioner for handling by the Attorney General, and a copy thereof shall be transferred to the attention of the Minister;
(4)the complaint concerns an act in respect of which legal proceedings are pending, including civil proceedings, criminal proceedings commencing from the investigation stage, or disciplinary proceedings, including proceedings pursuant to the Bar Association Law, 5721-1961, or an act in respect of which such proceedings were held and the court decided on the merits;
(5)the complaint concerns an act in respect of which an examination of a public complaint is being conducted by the Public Complaints Commissioner pursuant to the State Comptroller Law, 5712-1958 [Consolidated Version] (in this Law – the State Comptroller Law), or by any other authority authorised to examine complaints pursuant to law, or an act in respect of which such an examination was conducted and the Commissioner or the other competent authority, as the case may be, decided on the merits;
(6)
(a)the complaint concerns the exercise of legal discretion; if a question arises as to whether the complaint concerns the exercise of legal discretion, the question shall be referred to the Attorney General for decision, and the Commissioner shall stay the examination of the complaint until the said question is decided; if the Attorney General decides that the complaint concerns the exercise of legal discretion, the examination of the complaint shall be discontinued; for this purpose, "legal discretion" – includes discretion in making decisions regarding the manner of conducting and preparing proceedings;
(b)the authority of the Attorney General under sub-paragraph (a) is not delegable;
(7)the Commissioner considers that the respondent's superior or any other factor is the appropriate factor for examining the complaint in the circumstances of the matter; if the Commissioner so considers, the Commissioner shall transfer the complaint to the respondent's superior or to the factor found appropriate for examining the complaint as aforesaid, as the case may be, and that factor shall decide whether to examine it;
(8)the complaint concerns an act of the respondent that relates to proceedings pending before a forum; however, the Commissioner may examine such a complaint concerning unjustified delay in actions taken by a state representative in courts; the Commissioner shall not decide to examine such a complaint except with the approval of the Attorney General; for this purpose, "proceedings pending before a forum" – includes proceedings in respect of which an appeal or appeal to a forum may still be filed.
(b)The Commissioner shall not examine complaints as set out below, unless the Commissioner finds that there is a special reason justifying their examination:
(1)the complaint concerns one of the following:
(a)an act against which, pursuant to law, an appeal or appeal to a forum could have been filed, if the time limit for filing them has elapsed and they were not filed;
(b)an act against which, pursuant to law, an objection may be filed with a factor that is not a forum, even if it is called an appeal or by a different name, whether or not the time limit for filing the objection has elapsed;
(2)the complaint concerns an act in respect of which the appropriate body to hear and decide is the forum hearing the proceedings in the framework of which the said act was committed, provided that the complainant was a party to those proceedings;
(3)the complaint was filed after one year has elapsed from the day of the act that is the subject of the complaint or from the day the cause of the complaint became known to the complainant, whichever is later, and if the complaint relates to an act concerning legal proceedings that have ended – one year from the day a final judgment was given in those legal proceedings.
(c)If the Commissioner decides not to examine a complaint, the Commissioner shall notify the complainant thereof in writing, together with reasons, and a copy of the notice shall be delivered to the respondent and to the respondent's superior.
(d)If the respondent claims that the complaint against the respondent should not be examined by reason of one of the grounds set out in subsections (a) or (b), and the Commissioner decides to reject the claim and to examine the complaint, the Commissioner shall notify the respondent, the respondent's superior and the complainant of the decision.
(e)If a person who is a direct or indirect superior of the respondent notifies the Commissioner in writing that the respondent acted pursuant to the instruction of a senior professional factor or in compliance with binding procedures or accepted work practices, the Commissioner may discontinue the examination of the complaint; if the said professional factor is a state representative in courts, the Commissioner may determine that for the purpose of continuing the examination of the complaint, the said professional factor shall be the respondent, and the name of the original respondent shall be deleted from the complaint and the examination in respect of that respondent shall be discontinued.
(f)The Commissioner may discontinue the examination of a complaint if the Commissioner considers that the complainant or a person on the complainant's behalf has published the particulars of the complaint including the name of the respondent, with the purpose of harming the respondent or influencing the proceedings of the examination of the complaint.

Manner and Duration of Examination§

17.
(a)The Commissioner may examine the complaint in any manner the Commissioner sees fit and is not subject to rules of procedure or rules of evidence.
(b)If the Commissioner decides to commence examination of the complaint, the Commissioner shall bring the complaint to the attention of the respondent and to the attention of the respondent's superior, shall transmit to them all material or information relating to the matter that is in the Commissioner's possession and any additional material or information as aforesaid that comes into the Commissioner's possession in the course of the examination, and shall give each of them a suitable opportunity to respond to the complaint, and may also require them to respond within the period specified in the requirement and in the manner the Commissioner determines, including attaching supporting documents in support of the response, if any.
(c)For the purpose of examining the complaint, the Commissioner may hear the complainant or any other person in any manner the Commissioner sees fit.
(d)If the Commissioner considers that the respondent may be harmed by the results of the examination, the Commissioner shall notify the respondent thereof and shall give the respondent a suitable opportunity to present the respondent's arguments in the manner the Commissioner sees fit and within a period the Commissioner determines.
(e)If the Commissioner considers that another person may be harmed by the examination or its results, the Commissioner shall notify that person thereof, shall transmit to that person all material or information relating to the matter that is in the Commissioner's possession, and shall give that person a suitable opportunity to present that person's arguments in the manner the Commissioner sees fit and within a period the Commissioner determines.
(f)For the purpose of the examination, the Commissioner may receive from any person or body, within a period the Commissioner determines and in the manner the Commissioner determines, any information or document that the Commissioner considers may assist in the examination of the complaint, including matters communicated within proceedings in a court hearing in camera pursuant to section 68(b) of the Courts Law [Consolidated Version], 5744-1984, and all except information or a document that the Attorney General considers that their transmission to the Commissioner may cause significant harm to vital public interests; if the Commissioner receives information or a document that the Commissioner is not permitted to receive as aforesaid, the Commissioner shall not use it for the purpose of examining the complaint.
(g)A person required to provide information or a document as referred to in subsection (f) shall comply with the requirement and shall be obliged to answer correctly every question put to that person by the Commissioner, except questions whose answers would expose that person to the risk of criminal liability.
(h)Examination of the complaint shall be completed as soon as possible, and no later than within one year from the day it was filed, unless it cannot be completed by the said date for reasons that shall be recorded.

Discontinuation of Examination§

18.
(a)The Commissioner shall discontinue the examination of the complaint if the Commissioner ascertains that a ground has arisen that would justify not commencing the examination of the complaint pursuant to this Law.
(b)The Commissioner may discontinue the examination of the complaint if the Commissioner ascertains that any of the following has occurred:
(1)the subject matter of the complaint has been remedied;
(2)the complainant has withdrawn the complaint;
(3)the complaint relates to a factor who has ceased to be a state representative in courts.
(c)If the respondent claims that the respondent's ability to defend against the complaint is significantly prejudiced by reason of the fact that information required for the respondent's defence is information whose transmission to the Commissioner may cause significant harm to vital public interests, and the Attorney General finds the claim to be justified, the Attorney General may notify that the examination of the complaint is to be discontinued, and the Commissioner shall discontinue the examination thereof.
(d)If the Commissioner discontinues the examination of the complaint as referred to in this section, the Commissioner shall notify the complainant, the respondent and the respondent's superior thereof in writing, together with reasons, and a copy of the notice shall be delivered to the Minister and to the Attorney General.

Results of the Examination§

19.
(a)If the Commissioner finds that the complaint was justified, the Commissioner shall notify the complainant, the respondent and the respondent's superior thereof; in such a notice the Commissioner may detail a summary of the Commissioner's findings, all or in part; the Commissioner may recommend to the respondent and to the respondent's superior the need to remedy a deficiency that emerged from the examination and the manner and time for remedying it; a copy of the decision shall be delivered to the responsible Minister and to the Attorney General.
(b)If a recommendation for the need to remedy a deficiency as referred to in subsection (a) is accepted, the respondent and the respondent's superior shall notify the Commissioner of the steps taken to remedy the deficiency; if such notification is not received within a reasonable time, or if the notification does not satisfy the Commissioner, the Commissioner may bring the matter before the responsible Minister and the Attorney General.
(c)If the Commissioner finds that the complaint was not justified, the Commissioner shall notify the complainant, the respondent and the respondent's superior thereof, and shall state the Commissioner's reasons; in such a notice the Commissioner may detail a summary of the Commissioner's findings, all or in part.
(d)If the examination of the complaint raises a concern that a criminal offence has been committed, the Commissioner shall bring the matter to the attention of the Attorney General; if the examination of the complaint raises a concern that a disciplinary offence has been committed, the Commissioner shall bring the matter to the attention of the responsible Minister and the Attorney General.

Page 1 of 2

Read the entire law on one page — continuous text, no page breaks, plus formal citations.

LawAdministrative Law

חוק נציבות תלונות הציבור על מייצגי המדינה בערכאות, תשע"ו-2016

Public Complaints Commissioner Law

State Representatives Courts Law

Natziv Tolanot Law

Public Ombudsman Law

State Representatives Commissioner

Complaints on State Representatives Law

Courts Commissioner Law 2016

Public Complaints on Judges Law

Judicial Complaints Law

State Representatives Ombudsman