Israeli Legislation.com

Foster Care for Children (Complaint Mechanism for Children in Out-of-Home Placement) Regulations, 5779-2019

תקנות אומנה לילדים (מנגנון תלונה לילדים במסגרת השמה חוץ-ביתית), תשע"ט-2019

Published: 2019-01-02Consolidated Hebrew text as of 2023-09-18 · Last amended 2021-09-14
Premium
Unofficial English translation — for reference only. It may contain errors or omissions and cannot be relied on as a legal text. Only the Hebrew text published in Reshumot is legally binding.More

This English text was translated from the official Hebrew using a range of translation tools, and it undergoes ongoing checks and updates. It is not a certified translation.

Despite these checks, it may contain errors, omissions, or imprecise renderings of legal terminology and cross-references, and it may not yet reflect the latest amendments. It cannot be relied upon as a legal text.

The Hebrew text as published in Reshumot (ספר החוקים) and on the Knesset website is the sole authoritative and legally binding version. In any discrepancy, the Hebrew text prevails.

This translation is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For use in legal proceedings, request a certified Expert Legal Opinion.

By virtue of my authority under Sections 56(i) and 68 of the Foster Care for Children Law, 5776-2016 (hereinafter – the Law), with the approval of the Labour, Welfare and Health Committee of the Knesset, I hereby make these Regulations:

definitions§

1.

In these Regulations –

"duty to report" – as its meaning in section 368d of the Penal Law, 5737-1977;

"Penal Law" – Penal Law, 5737-1977;

"Complaints Commissioner" – the Complaints Commissioner as its meaning in section 56 of the Law;

"Service Accessibility Regulations" – Section B of Chapter V of the Equal Rights for Persons with Disabilities Regulations (Accessibility Adjustments for Service), 5773-2013.

Right to Apply to the Children's Complaints Commissioner§

2.
(a)Every child placed in an out-of-home placement is entitled to apply to the Complaints Commissioner and to submit a complaint independently, confidentially and freely and without fear of harm as a result of submitting the complaint; a child in foster care is entitled to complain as aforesaid in respect of everything relating to his or her day-to-day life in foster care, and a child in another out-of-home placement is entitled to complain as aforesaid in respect of everything relating to his or her stay in that placement.
(b)Every child placed in an out-of-home placement shall receive from the social worker at the department for social services, prior to placement, a card containing all the means of applying to the Complaints Commissioner, and shall also receive from that social worker information about the possibility of applying to the Complaints Commissioner and the manner of applying to him or her, as well as additional ways of submitting complaints; the information shall be provided to the child in a language that he or she understands, and in a form appropriate to his or her evolving capacities and special needs, if any; if the child is a child with a disability, the card and the information shall be provided to the child in accordance with the Service Accessibility Regulations, in a manner appropriate to his or her special needs; the social worker who provided the card and the information as aforesaid is required to document the performance of the action in the family file maintained at the department.
(c)In addition to what is stated in sub-regulation (b) –
(1)a foster care supervisor shall explain to a child placed in foster care, close to the placement and no later than three months from the commencement of the placement, about his or her right to submit a complaint independently, confidentially and freely, at any time and in respect of everything relating to his or her day-to-day life in foster care, as well as the ways of submitting the complaint; the information shall be provided to the child in a language that he or she understands, and in a form appropriate to his or her evolving capacities and special needs, if any; in addition, the foster care supervisor shall provide the child with an explanation as aforesaid at least once every three months during his or her stay in foster care; the foster care supervisor shall verify at all the said times that the child has in his or her possession a card as referred to in sub-regulation (b) and that the means of making contact with the Children's Complaints Commissioner are accessible to the child while maintaining privacy, and shall also take care to teach the child how to operate each such means;
(2)for a child placed in an out-of-home placement that is not foster care, the social worker of the placement shall take care, upon the child's admission to the placement, to show where the means of making contact with the Complaints Commissioner are located, and shall also take care to teach the child how to operate each such means; likewise, a social worker of the placement shall explain to the child, close to the placement and no later than three months from the commencement of the placement, about his or her right to submit a complaint independently, confidentially and freely, at any time and in respect of anything relating to his or her stay in that placement, as well as the ways of submitting the complaint; the information shall be provided to the child in a language that he or she understands, and in a form appropriate to his or her evolving capacities and special needs, if any; in addition, the social worker of the placement shall provide the child with an explanation as aforesaid at least once every six months during his or her stay in the placement; the social worker shall verify at all the said times that the child has in his or her possession a card as referred to in sub-regulation (b) and that the means of making contact with the Complaints Commissioner are accessible to the child.

Obligation to Install a Telephone and to Publish the Details of the Complaints Commissioner§

3.
(a)The manager of an out-of-home placement that is not foster care is responsible for ensuring that a telephone that is accessible to children in the placement is installed in a public and discreet location in the placement, from which outgoing calls can be made to the telephone number of the Children's Complaints Commissioner without the need for prior approval to use the telephone for that purpose; in addition to what is stated in any law, the placement is prohibited from listening to or recording the calls to the Complaints Commissioner as aforesaid; nothing in this sub-regulation shall derogate from a child's right to use a telephone belonging to him or her or another telephone, or from the prohibition on listening or recording under any law.
(b)The manager of an out-of-home placement that is not foster care is responsible for publishing the details of the Complaints Commissioner, and the ways of submitting a complaint, including the address for correspondence, in the wording that the Commissioner shall direct, in at least the following locations: in a location conspicuous to the eyes of the placed children, situated in the dining room of the placement or in the place used for serving food to the children in the placement, and also in an equally conspicuous location situated in a public area of the placement.

Manner of Submitting a Complaint§

4.
(a)A complaint to the Children's Complaints Commissioner shall be submitted by the child placed in an out-of-home placement, personally or by a close friend of his or hers, orally or in writing, including by way of drawing, by means of direct approach, by post, by electronic mail, by telephone, by text message or by any other means available for making contact as aforesaid; a complaint to the Children's Complaints Commissioner submitted by a litigation guardian or a lawyer appointed by a court for a minor shall be in writing, by post or electronic mail.
(b)A child who wishes to submit a complaint in writing and is unable to send it personally shall pass it in a sealed envelope through the foster care supervisor or the social worker in the out-of-home placement that is not foster care, as the case may be, the family's social worker, an instructor, a house mother, or any other professional or therapeutic party with whom the child meets, or through a close friend, and they shall pass it to the Complaints Commissioner directly and without any delay and without opening the envelope.
(c)Nothing in sub-regulations (a) and (b) shall derogate –
(1)from the possibility of a child placed in an out-of-home placement that is not foster care to submit a complaint directly during visits by the Commissioner or anyone on his or her behalf to the placement itself;
(2)from the application of the Service Accessibility Regulations in respect of the submission of a complaint by children with disabilities.
(d)As far as possible, the child shall indicate in the complaint the means of making contact with him or her.
(e)The Minister shall direct the working hours of the Complaints Commissioner or anyone on his or her behalf, in a manner that meets the needs of children in an out-of-home placement.

Time Limits§

5.
(a)The Complaints Commissioner or anyone on his or her behalf shall acknowledge receipt of the complaint within 5 working days from the day of its receipt, in a manner that ensures the confidentiality of the submission of the complaint and its contents, and that does not give rise to concern of harm to the complaining child as a result of the submission of the complaint.
(b)The duration of the examination of the complaint shall not exceed ninety days; the Complaints Commissioner shall take care to update the child or the person who submitted the complaint on his or her behalf once a month regarding the examination being conducted following the complaint.

Complaints Not to Be Investigated§

6.
(a)The Complaints Commissioner shall not investigate a complaint, or a part thereof, that is as set out below:
(1)a complaint whose main subject is a matter that is itself pending before a court or tribunal or that a court or tribunal has decided on the merits;
(2)a complaint that the Commissioner considers does not disclose grounds for intervention;
(3)a complaint about a judicial act, a quasi-judicial act or a decision of a statutory committee;
(4)a complaint to which the duty to report applies; if a complaint to which the duty to report applies has been received, the Complaints Commissioner shall act to fulfil the obligation under the Penal Law, 5737-1977;
(5)a complaint that the Complaints Commissioner has been persuaded, after an inquiry conducted with the complainant, that investigating it will cause the complainant significant harm exceeding the harm that would be caused by not investigating it.
(b)Where a complaint has been submitted that, pursuant to sub-regulation (a), is not to be investigated, the Complaints Commissioner shall notify the complainant in writing, or in any other manner that the Commissioner considers appropriate for updating the complainant having regard to the complainant's age, condition and evolving capacities, that the Commissioner will not deal with it, and shall state the reasons therefor.

Manner of Investigation§

7.
(a)The Complaints Commissioner may investigate the complaint in any manner that the Commissioner considers appropriate, and is not bound by any rule of procedure or rules of evidence.
(b)For the purpose of the investigation, the Commissioner may require any person to provide any information or document that the Commissioner considers may assist in investigating the complaint; a person required to provide information or a document as aforesaid is obliged to comply with the requirement, and Section 11 of the Commissions of Inquiry Law, 5729–1968, shall apply, with the necessary modifications, to a refusal to comply with the requirement.
(c)The Complaints Commissioner may require that the response to a requirement as referred to in sub-regulation (b) be given within a period that the Commissioner shall direct.
(d)In investigating the complaint, the Commissioner shall ensure the protection of the privacy, security and wellbeing of the child who submitted the complaint or in whose name it was submitted, and of other children, and shall avoid as far as possible the disclosure of information transferred from or about the child, except for information that the child has agreed to disclose.
(e)When investigating a complaint submitted by a child, including in respect of all that is required under these Regulations, communication with the child shall be conducted in a form and language appropriate to the child's comprehension ability according to his or her evolving capacities and special needs, if any, and in the case of a child with a disability – also in accordance with the Service Accessibility Regulations.
(f)The Complaints Commissioner shall document the Commissioner's conversations with the child or the complainant, if any.

Discontinuation of Investigation§

8.
(a)The Complaints Commissioner may discontinue the investigation of the complaint if the Commissioner has ascertained that one of the grounds justifying not opening an investigation has been met, or if the complainant has withdrawn the complaint; however, the withdrawal of the complaint does not in itself constitute a ground for discontinuing the investigation, and the Complaints Commissioner may continue investigating it despite the withdrawal if the Commissioner considered that investigating the complaint is required in order to protect the welfare of the child or of other children.
(b)Where the investigation of the complaint has been discontinued pursuant to this regulation, the Complaints Commissioner shall notify the complainant in writing, or in any other manner that the Commissioner considers appropriate for updating the complainant having regard to the complainant's age, condition and evolving capacities, that the Commissioner has decided to discontinue the investigation, and shall state the reasons for the decision.

Findings of the Complaints Commissioner§

9.
(a)Without derogating from Section 56(g) of the Law, if the Complaints Commissioner found, at the conclusion of the investigation, that the complaint was justified, in whole or in part, the Commissioner shall act as set out in paragraphs (1) to (3) below:
(1)the Commissioner shall notify the complainant thereof by a reasoned notice, in writing, or in any other manner that the Commissioner considers appropriate for notifying the complainant having regard to the complainant's age, condition and evolving capacities, and shall also notify thereof in writing the person against whom the complaint was made, provided that such notice does not harm the welfare of the child; the Complaints Commissioner shall also notify thereof the relevant inspector and the responsible district director;
(2)if the investigation of the complaint has revealed that a deficiency exists, the Complaints Commissioner may recommend to the person against whom the complaint was made and to the relevant inspector, the need to remedy the deficiency and the manner and time for doing so; the Complaints Commissioner may also recommend to the Director General of the Ministry, to the person in charge of foster care licensing or to the national foster care supervisor, and in the case of a child in an out-of-home placement that is not foster care – to the manager of the placement and to the inspector of the placements, to take appropriate measures against the person complained against and the measures required to prevent harm to the child or to other children, including a recommendation to terminate a foster care arrangement, to revoke a foster care licence or to revoke a licence for a placement under the Supervision of Institutions Law, 5725-1965, to transfer a child from a foster family or from an out-of-home placement that is not foster care, and also to suspend or transfer an employee in an out-of-home placement that is not foster care; the Commissioner may also recommend to them other measures for remedying the deficiencies that emerged from the investigation of the complaint, and the times for taking them; the Complaints Commissioner may require the relevant inspector to report on the remedying of the deficiencies and the implementation of the recommendations under this paragraph;
(3)if the investigation of the complaint has given rise to a suspicion that a criminal offence has been committed against a child or a concern that a disciplinary offence has been committed under any law, the Complaints Commissioner shall bring the matter to the attention of the legal adviser of the Ministry; nothing in this paragraph shall derogate from the obligation to report under the duty to report.
(b)If the Complaints Commissioner found that the complaint was not justified, the Complaints Commissioner shall notify the complainant in writing, or in any other manner that the Commissioner considers appropriate for updating the complainant having regard to the complainant's age, condition and evolving capacities, and the person against whom the complaint was made, and shall set out the Commissioner's findings, provided that such notice does not harm the welfare of the child; the Commissioner shall also transmit a copy of the notice to the relevant inspector.

Duty of Confidentiality§

10.
(a)The Complaints Commissioner, the Commissioner's employees and any other person with whose assistance the Commissioner performs the Commissioner's functions are obliged to keep secret any information that has come to their knowledge by reason of their work.
(b)Notwithstanding what is stated in sub-regulation (a), the Complaints Commissioner may decide to transfer documentation of a complaint dealt with in the matter of a child to the child's personal file, if the Commissioner has found a need for such documentation in order to protect the welfare of the child and while protecting the child's privacy.

Report§

11.
(a)The Complaints Commissioner shall submit to the Labour, Welfare and Health Committee of the Knesset a report on the Commissioner's activities, on 20 November of each year, on, inter alia, the following matters:
(1)the number of complaints submitted and the number of complaints investigated;
(2)the number of complaints found to be justified;
(3)the reasons for not investigating complaints;
(4)the average investigation time for complaints that were investigated;
(5)the number of complaints whose investigation has not yet been completed;
(6)the types of matters about which complaints were submitted.

Publication§

12.

The Minister shall publish the details of the Children's Complaints Commissioner and the ways of submitting a complaint and the address for correspondence also on the Ministry's website, and shall also publish these details through additional media at least once a year.

Commencement and Transitional Provisions§

13.
(a)These Regulations shall come into force 3 months from the day of their publication (in this regulation – the commencement date).
(b)In respect of a child who was in an out-of-home placement on the eve of the publication of these Regulations, the foster care supervisor or the social worker in the placement, as the case may be, shall take care to carry out the provisions of regulation 2(c) in respect of that child for the first time within three months from the commencement date.

Read the entire law on one page — continuous text, no page breaks, plus formal citations.

RegulationsWelfare & Social Security

תקנות אומנה לילדים (מנגנון תלונה לילדים במסגרת השמה חוץ-ביתית), תשע"ט-2019

foster care complaint mechanism

takkanot umnut lilyadim

out-of-home placement regulations

child complaint mechanism regulations

foster care regulations 5779

umnut lilyadim takkanot

children's complaint procedure foster care

out-of-home care complaint

foster care 2019 regulations

child welfare complaint mechanism