Israeli Legislation.com

Auditors (Conflict of Interest and Harm to Independence as a Result of Another Occupation) Regulations, 5768-2008

תקנות רואי חשבון (ניגוד עניינים ופגיעה באי-תלות כתוצאה מעיסוק אחר), תשס"ח-2008

Published: 2008-03-10Consolidated Hebrew text as of 2026-09-14 · Last amended 2020-05-21
Premium
Unofficial English translation — for reference only. It may contain errors or omissions and cannot be relied on as a legal text. Only the Hebrew text published in Reshumot is legally binding.More

This English text was translated from the official Hebrew using a range of translation tools, and it undergoes ongoing checks and updates. It is not a certified translation.

Despite these checks, it may contain errors, omissions, or imprecise renderings of legal terminology and cross-references, and it may not yet reflect the latest amendments. It cannot be relied upon as a legal text.

The Hebrew text as published in Reshumot (ספר החוקים) and on the Knesset website is the sole authoritative and legally binding version. In any discrepancy, the Hebrew text prevails.

This translation is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For use in legal proceedings, request a certified Expert Legal Opinion.

By virtue of my authority under Sections 10, 11 and 17 of the Auditors Law, 5715-1955, in consultation with the Institute of Certified Public Accountants in Israel and the Auditors Council, and with the approval of the Constitution, Law and Justice Committee of the Knesset, I hereby make these Regulations:

Definitions§

1.

In these Regulations –

"audit" – as defined in the Auditors (Auditor's Mode of Operation) Regulations, 5733-1973;

"directly or indirectly" – including by means of a corporation controlled by an auditor or by an auditors' corporation;

"family member" – a descendant, spouse, sibling, parent, and the spouse of each of them;

"first-degree family member" – a descendant, sibling, spouse and parent;

"second-degree family member" – the spouse of a first-degree family member;

"interested party" and "holding" – as defined in the Securities Law, 5728-1968 (hereinafter – the Securities Law);

"private company" – as defined in the Companies Law, 5759-1999 (hereinafter – the Companies Law), excluding a public benefit company as defined in that Law;

"public company" – as defined in the Companies Law, and including a company that is a reporting corporation as defined in the Securities Law;

"office holder", "security" – as defined in the Companies Law;

"client" – the auditee and any person who controls the auditee;

"auditee" – a person whose financial statements an auditor audits; where consolidated financial statements have been prepared for that person as defined in generally accepted accounting principles – also any person consolidated in those consolidated financial statements;

"audit firm" – an auditor and the accountants employed by that auditor or by the auditors' corporation in which the auditor is a partner or member, or by corporations controlled by the auditors' corporation;

"senior employee", where employed by the auditor – an employee ranked in one of the two highest pay or remuneration grades among employees employed at the same workplace;

"another occupation" – an occupation that is neither an audit nor a review of financial statements;

"relative" – a family member who resides with the person, a person who is dependent on that person for their livelihood, a person on whom that person is dependent for their livelihood, as well as a corporation controlled by any of them or a trustee for the benefit of any of them;

"auditor" – a handling accountant, the auditors' corporation in which the handling accountant is employed, a partner, member or shareholder, as well as the accountants who are partners, members or shareholders in that auditors' corporation, and including accountants employed in a supervisory union as defined in section 20 of the Co-operative Societies Ordinance; all of the foregoing except those who operate outside Israel on a permanent basis;

"handling accountant" – the accountant responsible on behalf of the audit firm for conducting the audit of a particular auditee, as well as the audit team engaged in auditing that auditee;

"control" – as defined in the Securities Law, and for the purposes of the definitions of "audit firm" and "directly or indirectly" as well as regulations 2(b)(3) and 5(b) – including a presumption that a holder of 25% of the means of control in a corporation who has the ability to prevent the adoption of business decisions therein controls the corporation, as well as a presumption that a corporation in which the overwhelming majority of partners or shareholders are partners or shareholders in the auditors' corporation is controlled by the auditors' corporation;

"banking corporation" – as defined in the Banking (Licensing) Law, 5741-1981;

"auditors' corporation" – an auditors' company or an auditors' partnership;

"audit period" – the current period in respect of which the audit is being conducted, including the period of time until the date on which the auditor's opinion is given on the financial statements for the current period.

Circumstances of Possible Conflict of Interest or Harm to Independence§

2.
(a)An auditor is presumed to be in a conflict of interest or to have had their independence from the auditee harmed if, in the framework of an audit that the auditor conducts, the auditor is required to address matters in which the auditor, or a senior employee employed by the auditor who has a material influence on the audit work at the auditee or on the audit team engaged in the audit of the auditee, has a personal interest, including a financial interest therein, or to give an opinion or valuation, in whole or in part, including the conclusions or findings thereof, that the auditor or such a senior employee gave in the framework of another occupation, directly or indirectly; however, the foregoing presumption shall not apply in any of the following cases:
(1)due diligence conducted in respect of the auditee for the purpose of its acquisition prior to the auditor's appointment as auditor of the auditee, or due diligence for the purpose of acquiring an activity on behalf of the auditee or for the purpose of acquiring means of control in a corporation by the auditee, conducted prior to such acquisition, provided that the due diligence does not constitute a valuation;
(2)an opinion required for tax purposes, which was not prepared by the handling accountant and does not constitute a basis for data in the financial statements, and in respect of an auditor of a private company – which was not prepared by the handling accountant or does not constitute a basis for data in the financial statements.
(b)In addition to the provisions of sub-regulation (a), an auditor is presumed to be in a conflict of interest or to have had their independence from the auditee harmed if any of the following has occurred, directly or indirectly:
(1)the auditor received from the client, during the audit period, remuneration, a commitment to bonus remuneration or another benefit, contingent on the results of the auditor's engagement or on the client's financial condition (hereinafter – contingent income), except for contingent income received from the controlling shareholder of the auditee in respect of services provided to the controlling shareholder, which does not directly or indirectly relate to or influence the audit activity, and whose scope in the audit year does not exceed the scope of audit income from the auditee in that year;
(2)the auditor received from the client gifts, hospitality, or another significant benefit;
(3)total income from the same client exceeds 25% of the total income of the auditor, directly or indirectly, and if the auditor is employed, a member, partner or shareholder in an auditors' corporation – of the total income of the auditors' corporation and of corporations controlled by it; for the purposes of this paragraph it shall be a good defence if the circumstances set out therein arose during the first three years from the establishment of the audit firm, provided that the total income from that client did not exceed 33% of the total income of the auditor as stated in this paragraph;
(4)the existence of a significant outstanding fee debt from the auditee to the auditor whose due date for payment has passed, except where the auditee is subject to liquidation proceedings, a stay of proceedings or receivership proceedings in respect of its assets or principal assets under company law;
(5)the auditor made their engagement in the audit conditional upon being engaged in another occupation, directly or indirectly;
(6)the auditor, a relative of the auditor, or a senior employee employed by the auditor who has a material influence on the audit work at the auditee or on the audit team engaged in the audit of the auditee – maintained, directly or indirectly, including by means of a corporation under their control, a material economic or business relationship with the client, including with office holders of the client or other senior employees thereof who participate in making managerial decisions on its behalf, during the audit period or in the year preceding it, or during that period it is known that such a relationship will commence on a known date; for the purposes of this paragraph, "material economic or business relationship" – includes a material one-time transaction and includes supplier-client relationships, service provider-service recipient relationships, leasing of assets, business partnerships, joint transactions, joint asset ownership and the like, as well as the granting of loans to the client or the receipt of loans from the client; however, the following shall not be regarded as such a relationship: a loan to an auditor from a banking corporation on market terms and in the ordinary course of business, which is not material to the banking corporation; the purchase or leasing of an asset, goods or services, by the auditor, not for the purpose of trading therein, on market terms and in the ordinary course of business of the auditee, provided that the transaction in question is a routine transaction that is not material to the client and which, by its nature, character and terms, is intended for the general public or for a clientele – other than an audit firm – with special characteristics; or the receipt of remuneration from the client;
(7)the auditor, a relative of the auditor, or a senior employee employed by the auditor holds securities of the client at any rate, or is an interested party in the client, or the auditor or a relative of the auditor is an interested party in a corporation controlled by the client that has not been consolidated in the financial statements of the auditee; however, the foregoing shall not apply to a relative of the auditor who is an interested party by virtue of being a director or general manager of a corporation controlled by the client that has not been consolidated in the financial statements of the auditee;
(8)a family member of the auditor who is not a relative holds securities at a rate of 10% or more in the client; however, in the case of an auditee that is a private company, the foregoing shall not apply with respect to the holding of securities of a family member of the auditor who is not a relative, provided that all shareholders in the auditee have agreed in writing to the conduct of the audit by the auditor in whose family member who is not a relative the foregoing applies;
(9)the auditor has an economic or business relationship of a material and ongoing character with a clear business competitor of the auditee, which is not an engagement to receive a product or service in the ordinary course of business on market terms or on terms offered to a clientele – other than an audit firm – with special characteristics;
(10)the handling accountant, or any person who was involved in any way in discussions relating to the audit of the auditee, including discussions among partners in the audit firm, is or was an employee of that client or was otherwise employed by the client, and an employer-employee relationship existed between the client and that accountant during the audit period or in the year preceding it; however, the foregoing shall not apply to a person who was an employee or was otherwise employed by a person who controls the auditee in the year preceding the audit period and who is not the handling accountant;
(11)a person in the audit firm, or a family member or relative of the handling accountant, is an employee of the client or is employed by the client on a permanent basis during the audit period; in the case of an auditee that is a private company, the foregoing shall not apply with respect to a second-degree family member who is not a relative and who is an employee of the client or is employed by the client, if all shareholders in the auditee have agreed in writing to the conduct of the audit by the accountant in whose family member who is not a relative the foregoing applies;
(12)the tenure of a person from the audit firm as an office holder in a corporation that is a client, as well as the tenure of a relative or family member of the auditor as an office holder in a corporation that is a client; however, in the case of an auditee that is a private company, the foregoing shall not apply with respect to tenure as an office holder in the client of:
(a)a family member of the auditor who is not a relative and who is not the handling accountant;
(b)a second-degree family member who is not a relative of the handling accountant;

provided that all shareholders in the auditee have agreed in writing to the conduct of the audit by the accountant in whose family member who is not a relative the foregoing applies;

(13)the handling accountant conducted negotiations with the client, during the audit period, concerning the handling accountant's employment by the client outside the framework of the audit firm;
(14)a person in the audit firm, or a relative or first-degree family member of the auditor, participated or is actually participating, during the audit period, in making managerial decisions on behalf of the client;
(15)at the time of the issuance of the audit opinion there exists, between the auditor and the client, an ongoing legal dispute or a legal dispute in respect of which a claim has been filed with the court.

Special Occupations§

3.

Without derogating from the generality of what is stated in regulation 2, an auditor is presumed to be in a conflict of interest or to have had its independence from the auditee impaired if the auditor engaged or engages, during the audit period or in the year preceding it, directly or indirectly, in another occupation or in an activity as listed below:

(1)the practice of law as defined in the Bar Association Law, 5721-1961, on behalf of the client, except for actions permitted to an accountant by law;
(2)a person from the audit firm serves as liquidator, receiver, estate administrator or trustee of the client, except for a trust in which the trustee carries out instructions in respect of the trust assets without making managerial decisions;
(3)the auditor has been appointed to the role of arbitrator or mediator on behalf of the client, including in disputes between shareholders of the client; however, the foregoing shall not apply to an auditor who resolves a dispute between shareholders of the client by virtue of a provision in the company's articles of association that was set before 1 January 2008, provided that the activity does not give rise to a presumption that the auditor is in a conflict of interest or that the auditor's independence from the auditee has been impaired, by virtue of another provision of these Regulations;
(4)the provision of an expert opinion on matters of the auditee in the framework of legal proceedings, including arbitration or mediation, except where the auditor testifies on data known to it in the course of conducting the audit or its role as auditor, or where the auditor is not entitled by law to refuse to give the said opinion;
(5)the provision of an opinion on a financial statement of the client, where the statement includes particulars based on an opinion of a member of the audit firm in one or more of the following:
(a)assessment of economic value, including fair value, of liabilities or assets, including vehicle appraisals and real property appraisals, except for an assessment that serves a broad range of users;
(b)the existence of rights in assets or the existence of liabilities;
(c)assessment of the actual condition of assets;
(d)the preparation of a business plan that affects the life of the business;
(e)actuarial services;

all of the foregoing, except for an incidental opinion, not given by the handling accountant, concerning a business plan, asset or liability that is not material to the corporation's business;

(6)a valuation of the auditee, unless it was not prepared on behalf of the auditee and all of the following conditions are cumulatively met:
(a)it was prepared before the audit period;
(b)it was prepared on behalf of a person who was not the controlling shareholder of the auditee at the time of its preparation;
(c)it was not prepared by the handling accountant, unless the handling accountant prepared it before 1 January 2008;
(7)a person from the audit firm serves as internal auditor of the client or engages in internal auditing of the client on behalf of the internal auditor, in the framework of the internal auditor's role at the client;
(8)the auditor serves as company secretary or fulfils the functions of a company secretary even if holding a different title, at an auditee that is a public company;
(9)planning or implementation of information systems at the auditee that do not have a material effect on data audited in the financial statements;
(10)the provision of financial services to the client relating to the sale of securities of the client, including underwriting;
(11)ongoing engagement on behalf of the auditee as an investment adviser or engagement on its behalf as a portfolio manager; for this purpose, "investment adviser" and "portfolio manager" – as defined in the Investment Advice and Portfolio Management Regulation Law, 5755-1995;
(12)engagement in bookkeeping on behalf of an auditee that is a public company or on behalf of an auditee that is an association or a public benefit company whose annual turnover or the amount of donations it received in that year is NIS 5,000,000 or more; for the purposes of this paragraph and paragraph (13) –

"association" – as defined in the Associations Law, 5740-1980;

"turnover" – as defined in the Second Schedule to that Law;

(13)engagement by the handling accountant in bookkeeping on behalf of an auditee that is a private company, association or public benefit company, in respect of which none of the conditions referred to in paragraph (12) is met; for the avoidance of doubt, the foregoing shall not apply to engagement in bookkeeping by an employee of the audit firm who is not part of the audit team engaged in auditing that auditee.

Circumstances Requiring Disclosure§

4.
(a)Without derogating from the principle of independence and from the provisions of regulations 2 and 3 –
(1)an auditor who engages, directly or indirectly, in another occupation and disclosure thereof has not been given in the financial statements or in the board of directors' report of a public company, shall give disclosure thereof in its report that includes its opinion on the financial statements of the auditee; for this purpose, "another occupation" means one of the following:
(a)bookkeeping on behalf of the client;
(b)the provision of valuations to a corporation included in the consolidated financial statements, if the auditee's holdings in that corporation constitute 25% or more of the auditee's equity;
(c)the provision of valuations to the client during the audit period;
(2)disclosure as referred to in paragraph (1) shall also be given in respect of the following:
(a)the holding of securities in the client at a rate of 5% or more by a family member of an auditor, unless the auditor did not know and was not required to know thereof;
(b)a family member of the handling accountant who is not a relative being employed by or engaged by the client, if the situation referred to in the second part of regulation 2(11) exists;
(c)a family member of the auditor who is not a relative serving as an office holder of the client, if the situation referred to in the second part of regulation 2(12) exists.
(b)Disclosure as referred to in sub-regulation (a) shall also be given in respect of the ratio between the auditor's income from auditing, including audit of the reconciliation of financial statements for tax purposes as required by law, and the total income of the auditor from that client, received in respect of auditing or in respect of other occupations in which the auditor engaged during the year for which the audit was conducted, all directly or indirectly, unless the scope of income from other occupations does not exceed one third of the total income from that client, or the only other occupation in which the auditor engaged is bookkeeping on behalf of the client; for this purpose, engagement in bookkeeping shall be regarded as a sole occupation even if the auditor provided other services of negligible scope.

Experts and Advisers Who Are Not Accountants§

5.
(a)An auditor is presumed to be in a conflict of interest or to have had its independence from the auditee impaired if, in respect of an expert whose work the handling accountant makes use of in the framework of audit work, circumstances exist that constitute a breach of the accepted and customary audit standards with respect to the use by an auditor of the work of an expert, or if the requirements contained in those audit standards are not met in respect of that expert.
(b)An auditor is presumed to be in a conflict of interest or to have had its independence from the auditee impaired if, in respect of experts who are not accountants and who are routinely employed by the auditor or by the auditors' corporation in which the auditor is a partner or member, or by corporations controlled by it, during the period of employment of those experts, circumstances exist that, if they existed in respect of the audit firm, would give rise to a presumption under the provisions of these Regulations; for the purposes of this sub-regulation, employment for a period of at least three months in a year and at a scope of one half or more of the monthly employment hours during that period shall be regarded as routine employment.

Merger of the Client with Another Corporation or Acquisition of Control§

6.
(a)Where, during the audit period, a merger occurred between the client and another corporation, or where, during the audit period, control over another corporation was acquired by the client, an act performed by the auditor in relation to the other corporation before the merger or acquisition shall not be regarded as a circumstance giving rise to a presumption under these Regulations, provided that the auditor ceased, after the merger or acquisition, to perform the act that gives rise to the presumption, and provided further that disclosure was made thereof in the manner referred to in regulation 4.
(b)In this regulation, "another corporation" – a corporation that is not audited by the auditor immediately before the merger or acquisition.

The State as Client§

7.

Without prejudice to the principle of independence, where the auditee or the person who controls the auditee is the State, a Government ministry or an attached unit, the following shall not be regarded as circumstances giving rise to a presumption under these Regulations:

(1)connections or relationships of the auditor with the State, or fees, income or benefits received by the auditor from the State, if they are not directly connected to the activity of the auditee, to the supervision of the auditee or to the regulation of the auditee's activity;
(2)a professional relationship, whether for remuneration or without remuneration, between the auditor and a professional body within the State whose function is to supervise the auditee or to regulate the auditee's activity, if the professional relationship is required for the performance of the function of that body under law;
(3)the employment of a relative or family member of the auditor by the State, provided that the relative or family member has no influence, within the framework of that position, over the activity of the auditee, over the supervision of the auditee or over the regulation of the auditee's activity.

Obligation to Take Reasonable Measures§

8.

An auditor shall take reasonable measures to prevent the existence of a conflict of interest or harm to the auditor's independence in relation to the auditee.

Conduct Unbecoming the Dignity of the Profession§

9.

An act by an auditor in contravention of the provisions of these Regulations, which is not a trivial matter, constitutes conduct unbecoming the dignity of the profession.

Absence of Awareness§

10.

An act by an auditor in contravention of these Regulations shall not be regarded as a breach of their provisions if the auditor was not aware of the nature of the act or of the existence of the circumstances constituting the breach; for the purposes of this regulation, an auditor shall be regarded as aware even if the auditor suspected and refrained from making enquiries.

Auditor of a Foreign Company or a Dual-Listed Company§

11.

It shall be a good defence for an auditor of a public company that is a foreign company or a dual-listed company whose shares are listed for trading on a stock exchange in England or in the United States of America, if the auditor acted in good faith in accordance with the foreign law applicable to the auditor with regard to independence and prevention of conflict of interest of an auditor.

Rebuttable Presumption§

12.

For the avoidance of doubt, where a presumption is established in these Regulations, it is rebuttable, and in particular an auditor who is on trial in disciplinary proceedings for breach of the provisions of these Regulations is entitled to prove that the presumption has not been established.

Review of Interim Financial Statements§

13.

The provisions of these Regulations with regard to the conduct of an audit shall also apply to the review of interim financial statements by the auditor.

Savings Provisions§

14.

These Regulations are in addition to any law and to provisions given or prescribed under law.

Application and Commencement§

15.
(a)These Regulations shall not apply with respect to an audit period commencing during the year 2008, even if the auditor's opinion on the financial statements for that audit period is given after 31 December 2008, unless the circumstances giving rise to a presumption under these Regulations first arose after the said date.
(b)The commencement of these Regulations is on the 5th day of Tevet 5769 (1 January 2009) and they shall apply to audit periods commencing on the said date or thereafter.

26 Adar I 5768 (3 March 2008) Daniel Friedmann

Minister of Justice

Read the entire law on one page — continuous text, no page breaks, plus formal citations.

Made under

Other regulations under the Certified Public Accountants Law

RegulationsCorporate & Business

תקנות רואי חשבון (ניגוד עניינים ופגיעה באי-תלות כתוצאה מעיסוק אחר), תשס"ח-2008

Auditors Conflict of Interest Regulations

Auditors Independence Regulations

CPA Conflict of Interest 2008

Roei Cheshbon Regulations

Accounting Auditors Independence Law

Auditors Professional Independence

Conflict of Interest Auditors 5768

Another Occupation Auditors Regulations

CPAs Dual Employment Restrictions

Auditor Independence Standards Israel